Per Axbom

Getting real about technology…

Stockholm, Sweden

Per Axbom reply Twitter

↪ Replying to @MetaMikeBiggs

@MetaMikeBiggs Will do!

@MetaMikeBiggs It's honestly so bad I'm crying.. this should be compulsory reading for all Americans... in short the bulk of mentally ill patients are in jail, deprived of competent care, because there are no other beds. Will do a writeup when I'm done but it's hard to know where to begin...

@MetaMikeBiggs My writeup will likely more focus on how many illnesses, and the rulesets for diagnosing each of them, came about through the consensus of a group of white men, with very little science to back them up.

🔗 Originally posted on Twitter

Per Axbom Twitter

I am 45 pages into The Great Pretender by @scahalan and it's already one of the best books on mental illness I've read. I have goosebumps from the documented historic abuse and mistreatment of "patients". I have a feeling I know where this is heading as we approach present time.

If you don't know who Susannah Cahalan is, she is the person portrayed by @ChloeGMoretz in the film Brain on Fire, which is based on Cahalan's memoir with the same name.

Here's her Wikipedia page: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susannah_…

The title "The Great Pretender" comes from the "great pretender diseases". They are illnesses that look and appear as other conditions (such as insanity) and will be diagnosed as such unless someone dares question this verdict.

Hence my tweet earlier today. x.com/axbom/status/1…

The first two categories for mental illness in the US were simply "idiocy" and "insanity". By 1880 this had expanded into seven: mania, melancholia, monomania, paresis, dementia, epilepsy and dipsomania.

The diagnostic methodology, and treatment practices, left much to hope for.

People with the right status and money were keen on having troublesome family members committed to asylums. Charles Dickens tried to commit his wife Catherine so that he could pursue an affair with an 18-year old actress.

smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/new…

On 16 March, 1912 a leader in The Times explained suffragette militancy by attributing it to women’s “Insurgent Hysteria”. "When this [type of woman] has reached a certain age", a physician explained, “we know that there is no help in us”:

francesca-scriblerus.blogspot.com/2013/07/were-s…

British writer Lady Rosina's feminist views bothered ex-husband Sir Bulwer Lytton in his ambition for a seat in parliament - so he had her committed. Her own celebrity saved her. (He was the inventor the cliché "It was a dark and stormy night") blog.wellcomelibrary.org/2015/09/a-blig…

«During the twentieth century, neurology broke off into a distinct branch of medicine, and in doing so “claimed exclusive dominion over the organic diseases of the nervous system”—like stroke, multiple sclerosis and Parkinson's.»

«Meanwhile, psychiatrists took on the ones “that could not be satisfactorily specified by laboratory science”—like schizophrenia, depression, and anxiety disorders. Once a biological breakthrough was achieved, the illness moved out of psychiatry and into the rest of medicine.»

I'm now up to the point where it feels like this book has punched me in the stomach. And still I want everyone to read it. Thinking now of starting a neuroscience book club. Pleased that Calahan has gone through many of the science cons I reference in this thread: x.com/axbom/status/9…

A tweet summary of 400 pages: Mental health patients are treated like animals. The science is awry. Some care was improving from 60s. Biased research instigated reform. New, feigned confidence in mental diagnosis. All progress obliterated. Now tortured in jail. Yet still hope.

🔗 Originally posted on Twitter

Per Axbom Twitter

I never did that writeup so now I feel like I need to reread this book and make a mindmap. It really made an impression on me. If you want to feel more compassion for odd and inexplicable behavior, this is the book. Watching Brain on Fire with @ChloeGMoretz and having flashbacks. x.com/axbom/status/1…

Damn, in the movie, when she drew the clock, I went "her hemispheres have disconnected!". I've read too many neuroscience books and would feel way too confident in a neuroscience setting. Reminds me of my desire to observe a brain operation. Bet you didn't know that about me. 😬

Anyway the movie is worth watching. It's based on the true story of Susannah Cahalan and her memoir with the same name: Brain on Fire. She's written a second book now: The Great Pretender: The Undercover Mission That Changed Our Understanding of Madness. Getting it next :)

Also, this keen interest is why I am so very skeptical when it comes to the many pop-science behavioral economics books on the market right now. I believe their over_simplification is dangerous.

And why I start threads like this: x.com/axbom/status/9…

🔗 Originally posted on Twitter