As a kid I spent so many hours on Flight Simulator II (on my Atari 800XL), I finally believed I could cope well if I had to take over the controls of a commercial plane. đ . I mean I had TWO joysticks!
Per Axbom
@dcm
I was thinking from a user perspective that a tool like ChatGPT does not have a clear objective. But with the interpretation that the user has some sort of objective then everything does I suppose.
I was struck by how different a general-purpose chatbot is from an AI built for detecting anomalies in x-rays for example, where the objective is very clear. My assumption was then that the definition was once written with specific applications of machine learning in mind.
@elhult
Maybe it's just me but I don't get the impression that ChatGPT has an explicit or implicit objective for example.
Looking at the definition of AI by the Organization for Economic and Co-operation Development (OECD):
"An AI system is a machine-based system that, for explicit or implicit objectives, infers, from the input it receives, how to generate outputs such as predictions, content, recommendations, or decisions that can influence physical or virtual environments. Different AI systems vary in their levels of autonomy and adaptiveness after deployment."
Based on this, if a language model has no explicit or implicit objectives it is not an AI.
Nu har det gÄtt lite mer Àn ett Är sedan jag skrev min lÄnga text om AI-hajpen, och spelade in den som podd. Jag vÄgar pÄstÄ att den fortfarande hÄller.
« Det Àr aldrig sÄ lÀtt att bli lurad som under en pÄgÄende hajp. Det Àr mars 2023 och vi Àr mitt i den. Det Àr sÀllan jag sett sÄ mÄnga anamma en helt ny experimentell lösning med sÄ lite ifrÄgasÀttande. Just i detta nu Àr det oerhört viktigt att skaka av sig hypnosen och granska innehÄllet i den hÀr nya flaskan med AI som flertalet börjat smutta pÄ, eller redan börjat tanka sina företagsdatorer med. Ibland utan ledningens vetskap. »
Lyssna eller lÀs: https://axbom.se/ai-ansvar/
Jag ser mÄnga företag som har hÄllbarhet pÄ agendan, men fÄ rapporter om hur de anvÀnder AI med tanke pÄ den ökade el- och vattenförbrukning som det innebÀr. MÀter man det som en kostnad och betalar tillbaka i en annan Ànde? Utan den kalkylen och transparensen tÀnker jag att det Àr svÄrt att fÄ förtroende för budskap om hÄllbarhet och cirkulÀr ekonomi.
Kanske Àr det enklast att bara ignorera och köra pÄ som om den egna anvÀndningen av AI-tjÀnster inte spelar roll. Strunt samma om företagets bidrag till vatten- och elförbrukning ökar exponentiellt om man ÀndÄ precis bytt till ekologiskt kaffe och lÄgenergilampor i konferensrummet.
Om företaget vars tjÀnster man anvÀnder inte vill avslöja sin energiförbrukning Àr det en leverantör man gÀrna anlitar? Och hur förhÄller man sig i dÄ till ett hÄllbarhetstÀnk? Kalkylen blir svÄr tÀnker jag. Och i sÄ fall har nog företag inte sÄ bra koll pÄ den hÄllbarhet och cirkulÀra ekonomi som de gÀrna marknadsför.
Jag tar gÀrna emot tips pÄ företag och organisationer som gör en ansats att redovisa hur mycket mer energi deras verksamhet leder till i andra och tredje led, efter att alla anstÀllda anammar AI-tjÀnster.
Alternativt som uttryckligen bara sĂ€ger att de kör pĂ„ och hoppas nĂ„gon annan löser den dĂ€r obetydliga frĂ„gan om âenergiförbrukningâ.
För mig personligen Àr alla rapporter kring energi- och vattenförbrukning ett stort skÀl att undvika anvÀndningen av generativ AI, och dÄ kanske sÀrskilt verktyg för att generera bild och video. Dessa kostar inte bara oerhört i trÀning, tillverkning och anvÀndning utan Àven i till exempel lagring och bandbredd.
SÄ klart har företagsanvÀndare ansvar i detta Àven om man av ekonomiska skÀl gÀrna spelar ovetande. Kanske tÀnds insiktens lampa nÀr fakturorna för företagets molnlagring ökar markant. TyvÀrr Àr insiktens lampa alltför ofta ocksÄ av lÄgenergi-varianten just nu.
Men var Àr hÄllbarhetsrÄdgivarna i allt detta? Om man lÀr ut AI i skolan, pratar man om resurserna som krÀvs? Jag tÀnker att mÄnga ungdomar skulle ha Äsikter om de framtida vÀgvalen nÀr de förstÄr teknikens klimatpÄverkan.
Jag lÀser om hur mÀnniskor upprörs av nÄgons flygresa, och hickar till nÀr samma mÀnniskor i nÀsta stund publicerar exempel pÄ mÄnga av de bilder och filmer de sitter uppe pÄ nÀtterna och genererar, och uppmuntrar andra att göra ocksÄ. Att agera hÄllbart handlar idag mest om att inte göra det som riskerar ens eget rykte. De personliga relationernas accepterande attityd fÄr styra, snarare Àn intresse för faktisk pÄverkan.
Opinionen har Ànnu inte, med klimatpÄverkan i Ätanke, bidragit till en bredare kÀnsla av AI-skam. Kanske kommer det nÀr man kÀnner att den dÀr halvlitern vatten kan komma till bÀttre anvÀndning Àn att stÀlla 50 frÄgor till ChatGPT.
âDu ersĂ€tts inte av AI, du ersĂ€tts av en annan mĂ€nniska som anvĂ€nder AIâ, brukar det heta. Det Ă€r ett snyggt sĂ€tt att skrĂ€mma till anvĂ€ndning utan eftertanke. Men lĂ„ter det hĂ„llbart?
Hela texten, med vidare lĂ€sning, pĂ„ bloggen: đ
@rrwo đđđž
The fact that you are on floss.social made this response epic.
@timmymac Haha, exactly. Thatâs identifying the real harms!
Imagine a âsmartâ toothbrush. Through a bluetooth-enabled app on your phone, it is programmed to provide personalised feedback on your brushing habits based on time spent, pressure applied and area covered.
Now imagine worrying that adding more and more computing power to the toothbrush will create an all-powerful superbeing that erases mankind.
I get that vivid imaginations can end up there but that they are being taken so seriously, without any more coherent reasoning or explanation than âit feels like itâ, is truly baffling.
For a walkthrough of the many logical fallacies of believing computers will by themselves evolve into a "superbeing", I encourage you to read the first chapter of Moral Codes by professor Alan Blackwell.
The chapter also contains a great primer on the two main different kinds of AI. The first kind is what used to be called "cybernetics", or "control systems", with a sensor (like a thermostat) controlling an output (like a heating pump) . And the second kind of AI being the one that intends to imitate human behaviour for its own sake.
As Blackwell writes: "Many public discussions of AI do not acknowledge this distinction between the objectively useful and (sometimes) straightforward engineering of practical automated machinery, and the subjective philosophical enterprise of imitating the way that humans interact with each other."
Blackwell goes on to argue that many AI researchers have blurred the lines between computing and philosophy, without formal training in the latter. There is a great deal of magical thinking going on, with no basis in scientific reasoning.
«The magical powers of genies and deities are not precisely defined in stories, because clear definitions would limit the power of the narrative device. If anyone did commit to a technical definition of AGI, the contradictions would become clear, because the definition itself has to be coded in some way. Of course the answer canât be a circular one - you canât say that the necessary code definitions will be written by the AGI itself! Intelligence that could manifest itself in any way, without the inconvenience of a clear definition, is a plot device like the shape-changing T-1000 of Terminator II which might be described as an âartificial general bodyâ in the way it is unlimited by any definition of shape, and thus able, in the imaginary universe of the movie, to become anything at all.»
Read the chapter here.
https://moralcodes.pubpub.org/pub/1mn2q39n/release/6
And by all means, keep on reading after that đ
Jag rockar sockorna varje dag men idag Ă€r dagen nĂ€r mĂ„nga fler gör det ocksĂ„. Ălskar att kika under konferensbordet idag â€ïžđđ§Š
#WorldDownSyndromeDay firas den 21/3 för att uppmÀrksamma den unika uppsÀttningen med 3 exemplar av kromosom nummer 21.
NÄgra lÀnkar jag gillar att dela:
En film som beskriver hur Trisomi-21 funkar:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0VV3C_ydak
George Webster avfÀrdar 5 myter om Downs syndrom:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p09kyydg
Frank Stephens tal i FN 2018:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1d8ocuPrlT8
Den senaste kampanjfilmen âAssume that I can so maybe I willâ, inklusive ett portrĂ€tt av Madison Tevlin, stjĂ€rnan i filmen, och om inspirationen till filmen:
https://www.ds-int.org/Blog/assume-that-i-can
FrÄn svenska Downföreningen:
âI Sverige och i flera andra lĂ€nder uppmĂ€rksammar man VĂ€rldsdagen för Downs syndrom med att Rocka sockorna. Genom att ta pĂ„ dig olika strumpor 21 mars deltar du i firandet av dagen och visar att du stĂ„r upp för alla mĂ€nniskors lika vĂ€rde och rĂ€ttigheter.â
This.
The bias in generative AI is not a reflection of bias in society. Why would it be? It's a reflection of bias in the training data, which of course is very very far from a complete representation of the world. The training data is whatever the makers decided to throw in there and often even they have no idea how the soup is made or how well it represents any society or culture. And generative AI will then tend to amplify and exacerbate bias, because... maths.
Bonus insight: if you try to mitigate bias with inclusive prompting, it's not always that simple.
@ambivalena Ja, jag hade sjĂ€lv missat den i december sĂ„ det kĂ€ndes plötsligt jĂ€tteviktigt att hjĂ€lpa den att fĂ„ spridning. đ
A reminder that my chart The Elements of AI Ethics is available as a free PDF download. Use it as a reference and guide in teaching, evaluations, risk assessments and mitigation strategies.
Iâm currently also producing a âworksheet for AI trials in the workplaceâ as Iâm hearing of many organisations experimenting with generative AI without really documenting expected and real learnings and outcomes. I expect to publish it by next week.
The harmful effects of technology can be managed and mitigated. But not if we do not talk about them. Nor if we allow ourselves to be misled to focus on misleading narratives. In the chart The Elements of AI Ethics I map out harms that we are already seeing reports of, that have been ongoing and many of which were predicted before they happened. As a tool it can provide guidance and talking points for understanding how to prioritise your work with "smart" tools, and acknowledge that all teams that deploy or make use of AI need a mitigation strategy for many different types of harms.
This chart builds on The Elements of Digital Ethics (2021). The harms in the original diagram are all still relevant, and what this chart does is provide a focused overview of the types of harm we are seeing proliferate with the ongoing advancement of AI within different industries, and especially general-purpose and generative tools. You can refer to the original chart to get an idea of how a tool like this can be used in education and project work.
Jag har skrivit förr om det barnarbete som sker för att hela tiden utveckla digitala apparater, och Àven klara av den gröna omstÀllningen, men jag har inte rest för att bevittna detta pÄ plats.
Det gjorde dÀremot Staffan Lindberg och Magnus Wennman förra Äret, nÀr de reste till Madagaskar för att med egna ögon prata med de undernÀrda barnen som grÀver fram de mineraler som tillverkningen av elbilar krÀver.
Det Ă€r platsen för vĂ€rldens första klimatsvĂ€lt. Andra svĂ€ltkatastrofer i modern tid har utlösts av krig och konflikter. För sex Ă„r sedan, nĂ€r regnet slutade falla över södra Madagaskar, inleddes den första dĂ€r den globala uppÂvĂ€rmningen var huvudorsaken enligt FN.
«Laha och de andra barnen kĂ€nner inte till att mineralen de bryter anvĂ€nds till elbilar. De har knappt sett nĂ„got fossildrivet fordon, bortsett frĂ„n uppÂköparens lastbil och en och annan FN-jeep.
Lahas tankar gĂ„r till förĂ€ndÂringen som orsakade svĂ€lten.
Fingrarna knÀcker en liten bit glimmer.
â Om vi bara hade tillrĂ€ckligt med mat som förr skulle vi orka grĂ€va merâŠÂ»
Reportaget frÄn december Àr för mig en sammanfattning av samtiden. Hur drivet att bygga nytt ska rÀdda oss frÄn problemen som uppstÄtt ur besattheten vid att bygga nytt. Hur de som drabbas hÄrdast av problemen drabbas ytterligare. Hur osynliga, och osynliggjorda, de som drabbas Àr för de som gynnas. Att varumÀrken knappt pÄverkas av omstÀndigheterna. Att konsumtionen som lösning vinner om och om igen. Tills den inte gör det.
Vad betyder det att skriva pÄ en barnkonvention?
https://special.aftonbladet.se/story/jleydo
@bigbro It's a closed session, which I also think is key to valuable and open conversations. But I definitely want to share more of takeaways and learnings on my blog later.
@julian Thank you for sharing. This is my experience as well... at least a year of sorting things out.
One of my takeaways is that online platforms will have lots of settings for memorializing accounts or deleting them completely. But they arenât going to teach you how to download your content and make it available to your family in a sensible way.
It will actually be an open discussion as part of the session, what are designers' responsibilities. I'm also thinking of books, music, playlists that are likely to get lostâŠ
People have of course been talking about these things for a long time but I don't see any clear answers.
Designers at least carry much of the weight of consent, information and communication. My reflection is that this can generally be done in a much better and more proactive way. And assume responsibility and talking about it more openly is a step forward.
@JackEric The thought did cross my mind earlier but I kind of dropped it as I kept working on the presentation... but now that you mention it it actually makes sense to bring this up towards the end... things will go wrong and we will need to evaluate them.
Doing a session tomorrow on Postmortem Design - actually designing to protect the legacy of users after they pass away.
I'm prepping my slides and I'm already crying. So much data getting lost and so hard for families to access it.
I'm using my grandma's attic as a backdrop. I used to love heading up there and discovering old photos, letters, stamps, coins and memorabilia each with its own story.
Now who owns everyone's attic⊠do our digital legacies matter and if so, who should own it and access itâŠ
Sunday long-read on the environmental impact of data centers.
"Anthropologist Steven Gonzalez Monserrate draws on five years of research and ethnographic fieldwork in server farms to illustrate some of the diverse environmental impacts of data storage."
"Some have proposed relocating data centers to Nordic countries like Iceland or Sweden, in a bid to utilize ambient, cool air to minimize carbon footprint, a technique called âfree cooling.â However, network signal latency issues make this dream of a haven for green data centers largely untenable to meet the computing and data storage demands of the wider world."
"[âŠ] the Cloud now has a greater carbon footprint than the airline industry. A single data center can consume the equivalent electricity of 50,000 homes. At 200 terawatt hours (TWh) annually, data centers collectively devour more energy than some nation-states."
https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/the-staggering-ecological-impacts-of-computation-and-the-cloud/